| Opposition | | Date | Comp. | Score | Goalscorers | |
| Linfield | A | 09/07/11 | F | 1-6 | Lagan | |
| Malachians | A | 16/07/11 | F | 7-1 | Smith(2), Heatley(3), O'Neill, Deans | |
| Ballymoney United | A | 19/07/11 | F | 5-1 | Smith(2), Heatley, O'Neill, o.g | |
| Newington YC | A | 23/07/11 | F | 1-2 | P. Owens | |
| Annagh United | A | 26/07/11 | F | 3-2 | Heatley(3) | |
| Derriaghy CC | A | 02/08/11 | F | 4-0 | Lagan, P. Owens, McDowell, Heatley | |
| Cliftonville | A | 06/08/11 | CP | 0-1 | - | |
| Crusaders | H | 13/08/11 | CP | 1-2 | P. Owens | |
| Glenavon | A | 20/08/11 | CP | 2-1 | O'Neill, P. Owens | |
| Dungannon Swifts | A | 26/08/11 | CP | 1-3 | O'Neill | |
| Ballymena United | A | 30/08/11 | CP | 2-0 | McAlinden, Heatley | |
| Lisburn Distillery | H | 03/09/11 | CP | 0-0 | - | |
| Glentoran | A | 07/09/11 | CAS | 2-5 | McDowell, P. Owens | |
| Coleraine | A | 10/09/11 | CP | 0-4 | - | |
| Glentoran | A | 17/09/11 | CP | 1-6 | Harmon | |
| Sport & Leisure Swifts | H | 21/09/11 | LC | 6-1 | Hutchinson, McClean, Anderson, Heatley, Harmon, Stewart | |
| Linfield | A | 24/09/11 | CP | 0-3 | - | |
| Portadown | A | 01/10/11 | CP | 0-3 | - | |
| Donegal Celtic | A | 08/10/11 | CP | 2-1 | McAlinden, Lagan | |
| Limavady United | H | 12/10/11 | LC | 3-1 | McDowell, Heatley, Lynch | |
| Cliftonville | A | 15/10/11 | CP | 1-2 | O'Neill | |
| Ballymena United | H | 22/10/11 | CP | 0-2 | - | |
| Crusaders | A | 29/10/11 | CP | 1-5 | Heatley | |
| Dungannon Swifts | H | 05/11/11 | CP | 1-1 | O'Neill | |
| Glentoran | H | 12/11/11 | CP | 3-3 | o.g, McDowell, Heatley | |
| Crusaders | H | 16/11/11 | LC | 0-7 | - | |
| Coleraine | H | 18/11/11 | CP | 0-2 | - | |
| Linfield | H | 26/11/11 | CP | 0-4 | | |
| Glenavon | H | 03/12/11 | CP | 2-2 | O'Neill(2) | |
| Donegal Celtic | H | 09/12/11 | CP | 1-2 | McAlinden | |
| Lisburn Distillery | A | 17/12/11 | CP | 3-2 | P. Owens, Heatley, McDowell | |
| Portadown | H | 20/12/11 | CP | 2-2 | P. Owens, Lagan | |
| Dungannon Swifts | H | 27/12/11 | CP | 0-0 | - | |
| Lisburn Distillery | A | 31/12/11 | CP | 1-3 | Heatley | |
| Coleraine | H | 07/01/12 | CP | 0-4 | - | |
| Killymoon Rangers | A | 14/01/12 | IC | 3-1 | McDowell, Lagan(2) | |
| Glentoran | H | 21/01/12 | CP | 2-2 | McDowell, Kane | |
| Cliftonville | H | 28/01/12 | CP | 3-3 | O'Neill, K. Owens, Byrne | |
| Glenavon | A | 04/02/12 | CP | 2-3 | Hyland, O'Neill | |
| Linfield | A | 11/02/12 | IC | 1-5 | Dolan | |
| Ballymena United | H | 17/02/12 | CP | 1-3 | Dolan | |
| Donegal Celtic | H | 24/02/12 | CP | - | | |
| Linfield | A | 10/03/12 | CP | - | | |
| Portadown | H | 16/03/12 | CP | - | | |
| Crusaders | A | 24/03/12 | CP | - | | |